MASSENA - Despite a report from its auditor suggesting it should increase its rates, Massena Electric Department Superintendent Andrew J. McMahon said a rate increase is not in his plans for the near future.
Nobody has talked about it yet, Mr. McMahon said. Theres a difference between inevitable and imminent.
Board Chairman James M. Shaw agreed.
As long as it has been, sooner or later we will have to raise rates, but we havent done anything to that effect yet, Mr. Shaw said. A lot of things have changed in the past couple of years, like the state retirement rates, state insurance rates and the cost of materials.
Mr. McMahon said the price they pay for utility poles has increased 15 percent, transformers have increased 70 percent and the price for copper has doubled from what they were paying in 2006.
MED Treasurer Jeffrey M. Dobbins also noted that the state retirement rates have doubled in the past four years.
According to the audit, performed by William C. Freitag of Bollam, Sheed, Torani & Co., the utilitys net income has decreased from $553,000 in 2009 to only $134,000 in 2012. In 2011. MEDs net income was $339,000, $205,000 more than it was this past year, meaning a similar drop would have the utility losing money.
MED is at a crossroads, Mr. Freitag said. The gross profit built into the base rate you charge your customers is starting to erode.
Mr. Freitag said ideally the company would be see a rate of return of between 5 and 6 percent. Last years was less than 1 percent.
Your rates have done very well for you since they were put into place in 1981, he said. Operations costs for you, like everyone else, are going up.
One positive though is MED has nearly $4 million in available cash for operating expenses and another near $4 million available in various reserve accounts.
If you werent in as good of financial shape as you are, you would need a rate increase immediately, he said. Because of that you can delay the inevitable.
Town councilmen John F. Macaulay and Charles A. Chuck Raiti both attended the audit presentation, reporting back to the town board that a rate increase was on the horizon.
Mr. Macaulay said MED is getting close to a point in time where they need to consider a rate increase, noting they havent had a rate increase in forever.
But theyve got enough cash that they could get along for a period of time without a rate increase. Based on the trend, they would be starting to use reserves to cover their operating expenses, Mr. Macaulay said.
Councilman Charles A. Chuck Raiti commended MED for their efficiency and low cost for their customers.
Its the one service people have that they dont have to worry about from a cost standpoint, Mr. Raiti said.
And according to MEDs audit, Mr. Raiti is right.
In 2008, the average residential customer paid $830.45 for electric service, a cost thats actually higher than the $823.65 they paid on average in 2012.